Swing was a form of jazz that truly developed in the 1930s. People were more concerned with race in this time period due the concentration and emergence of jazz critics. Through the clash of Ellington vs. Hammond, a very important relationship of music performer and music critic formed. Jazz was transformed and closely analyzed during this time period. People began to start thinking about the culture and meaning behind the music, rather than just not even thinking about it. Before the 1920's people didn't really think about the jazz and where it came from. It was just a common known fact that many black people expressed themselves through jazz. Through the emergence of the music critic, swing music was thought of in a completely new way.
Race has always been involved with the creation of jazz. In the 1920's, people recognized that many jazz players were black and even though they played incredible music, whites felt superior to blacks. People had never really addressed this racial difference explicitly until the 1930's Swing Era. A critic of jazz named John Hammond rose to the forefront of the music scene. Hammond was a harsh critic and favored only certain jazz musicians such as Fletcher Henderson and Billie Holiday. However, Hammond was very critical of Duke Ellington. The rise of music critics served as a changing point in racial history because people began to explicitly state the differences between races in media.
One of the biggest controversies that involved Hammond was the clash between him and Duke Ellington. Ellington was a man who understood that during this time, it was essential to cooperate with whites in order to be successful in the music industry. Ellington described Hammond as, "an ardent propagandist and champion of the 'lost cause'"(Swing Changes pg. 51). Hammond in turn, questioned why Ellington didn't appreciate his black culture. For example, Hammond wrote, "he shuts his eyes to the abuses being heaped upon his race" (Swing Changes pg. 51). There is a strong irony with Hammond's criticism because Ellington was "explicitly and self-consciously concerned with African-American culture expression" (Swing Changes pg. 51). Ellington just didn't want to create conflict so that he could have the best opportunities to play his music. This feud was quite unique but showcased a "relationship that was crucial in shaping music and the cultural meaning of swing" (Swing Changes pg. 52).
During the 1930's to 1940's swing began to change and morph. Swing music "took on a more explicit set of ideological meanings" (Swing Changes pg. 53). Many reviews of jazz music decided to delve deeper into the meaning behind jazz and the political implications it enacted. Reviews of jazz music and the racial differences behind it lead to a change in the way jazz was looked at.
Also, important during this time was jazz competitions. Benny Goodman was one of considered to be the king of swing at this time. He was a white musician who was influenced by Hammond. Hammond suggested, "break with the segregated tradition that had governed public performances and recordings of jazz up to that time" (Swing Changes pg. 55). Goodman was able to perform extremely well even though he was not the typical type of jazz musicians showing the start of diminishing segregation in music. Goodman competed against Chick Webb who was a talented drummer. This competition of two talented musicians served to show that race is not the most important factor in jazz, but the talent that the person is capable of will reign supreme.
Commented on Rebecca Ent
I really enjoyed how you incorporated the clash of Ellington and Hammond as one of the reasons for the racial tension that became prominent in the 1930's. I like how you included how competition of two talented musicians served to show that race is not the most important factor in jazz, but the talent that the person is capable of will reign supreme. I made the same point in my blog and how Alain Locke was one of the first people to point out that talent is what makes someone powerful
ReplyDelete